This posting I have given the title: New Beginnings for a New Welsh Republicanism?

A rather opptimistic title, you might think from someone, as myself who is always wriiting critcally and often cynically on ''Welsh Republicanism''. The author of the material that follows is David Lawrence whom I had pleasure of meeting and getting to know a little, at the 1st March 2006 protest at opening of the 'Sham Senedd' and visit of members of the English Royalty to open this Assembly of Appeasement with English Imperialism. I had not the opportnunity then to talk much with David regards his ideas on ''Welsh Republicanism'', nor unfortunatly time to visit 'Republican Forums' to which David contributes. This past month I have been busy posting material on ''Welsh Republicanism'' to a number of blogs I work with, as the 'Aternative Welsh Nationalist Archive: http://awnms.blogspot.com posting to this blog information on the first Welsh Republican Movement 1946 - 56/7?. In another blog I work with at http://adfywiad.blogspot.com , you will usually find material where I pour scorn on present day so called ''Welsh Republicanism'' of such ''Retro - Romantic Rubbish'' put forward by ''grouplets'' as 'Cymru Rydd' and 'Balchder Cymru'. Essentially my arguement is that ''Welsh Republicanism'' never really existed, and that it was unfortunatly a failed ideology. The Welsh Republicanism of WRM I was a very promising attempt in the period from 1946 into the late fifthties, but the advent of the ''sixties'' witnessed successful advance of Plaid Cymru ''Progressive Nationalism?''and a language based cultural nationalist struggle led by Cymdeithas yr Iaith Cymraeg. Although a little influenced by the previous 'Welsh Republicnism' of Cliff Bere, Ifor Wilks, Pedr Lewis and Harri Web, Welsh Nationalist Radicalism in the ''sixties'' although sometimes referring to itself as ''Republican'' was in fact more so 'Ultra - Militant Nationalism' (See FWA) and Radically Patriotic (see Patriotic Front). An attempt to refound a more definable ''Welsh Republicanism'' was attempted in decades that followed, giving rise to WRM II and a Welsh Socialist Republican Movement, plus a kind of ''WRM'' in form of a paper 'Y Gwerineathwr' (named after paper of WRM I). Today, I had thought that any continuing ''Welsh Republicanism'' was not even really of an old ''Republican Rump'' but rather a ''Republican Remnant'' of the what I referr to as the ''Debris'' of 'To Dream of Freedom', if you have no idea regards what I mean, you will, if you read by 'Adfywiad Gwladgarol' Blog. The only other ''Welsh Republicanism'' I was aware of, was that of certain ''Left'' Plaid Cymru members, who subscribed to the Guardian Newspapers ''British Republican'' campaign. However, I am prooved wrong and indeed need to eat some ''humble pie'' for of late I have receieved material from David Lawrence, that perhaps will prove me wrong in my historical analysis and critcal contemporary cynicism. The material David has sent me, as impressed me, I publish some of it below and hope when you have read it, that you will be impressed too. For I believe, that if any New Welsh Republicanism is to arise then it will come out of the work that David is putting into establish some rock solid 'Welsh Republican Historic Foundations', as it can only be out of such will we see a NEW WELSH REPUBLICAN MOVEMENT(III/IV/V?) with a sound Welsh Republican Ethos and Creed, Philosophy and Theories essential to such movement and of course
'NEW WELSH REPUBLICAN STRUGGLE'. So read on:
Picture at top is of myself ''off to rise a Welsh Republican Flag at Garreg Wasted'', pictures below are mostly ''Socialist Republicans'' led by Leanne Wood gathering for the 1 March 2006 Anti - English Monarchy Protest at the 'Sham Senedd'.
The Foundations of a New Welsh Republicanism? (A title I have given to below, David would be too modest to call it such as he preferrs not to write articles, instead engaging in discussion and swapping of ideas. However, I am impressed enough to make ''no bones'' about how I view what he is doing, in terms of research and otherwise engaging with others of a 'Welsh Republican Mind' in forums, as noted below).
David writes:
Thought that I'd explain to you my hypothesis about the origins of Welsh republicanism in the 16c. My take on Welsh history however is not as good as yours, it is as impressionistic as my grasp of the off-side rule...any how, this is a sketch of my recent thoughts on the matter.The Welsh got very little out of Henry VII's victory considering what they put in and things remained much the same as before up to the "Union", the punitive and discriminatory laws imposed by Henry IV remaining in place. The "Union" that people discussed had some promising aspects to it, such as reuniting all the separately governed bits of Wales into one polity - albeit with England - and some people wanted it and argued for it. What they got was the Annexation, Reformation and Dissolution and a number of other things also which threw Wales into chaos and started a century-long downward spiral into civil unrest and finally a minor rebellion in 1609. Read an English textbook and it will tell you that 16c Wales was a happy and contented place after the "Union" with England, but that is not true. What is really interesting to me is that this society in turmoil acquired or developed those ideas that would be fused together later to emerge in the form of a democratic republicanism that is Wales' legacy to the modern political world.The Annexation was a rude awakening for those who hoped for Union with England : they got their single government in the shape of a Council for Wales and the Marches but only at the expense of Wales being declared non-existant as a state entity, its language being made non-legal and the rights of Welsh people before the law being subject to them becoming English speaking people. This antagonised people's sense of national pride in Welsh identity, but then they saw the king himself as "Welsh", being a Tudor, so there wasn't so much antagonism towards his nationality as towards his unjustness towards them which was blamed on his councillors. Wales did get a single legal system again, but an English one that was about to overthrow the church laws that had long defended those disadvantaged as Welsh people by the Crown and Marcher laws. In the subsequent Reformation that set the monarch above both the laws of the state and the church, the Welsh were deeply offended religiously and mostly thought of themselves less as patriots and more as Catholics opposed to a corrupt monarch who had set himself above the authority of the church laws that had previously made him subject to the Pope as a check on him becoming a tyrant. They also had a lot of their traditional holiday pleasures banned in the Reformation whilst they learned that Henry VIII was increasing the lavishness of his lifestyle. In the Dissolution the Welsh saw the king and wealthy people plundering the wealth and lands of the Church which had been effectively the common inheritance of ordinary people, their "welfare state" and often their employer. Churches were stripped of anything valuable like roofing lead and the monasteries, their schools, hospitals and poor houses, were made into private grand houses. The great libraries of Wales were destroyed and the farmland of the church was turned over to grazing animals that could then be driven to London for sale for cash profits for the Welsh gentry.The common people were forced off the good soil into the valleys and mountains to live a marginal existence both materially and culturally, and it was in this poor soil, that was promptly neglected by the newly established Anglican church whose priests collected parishes to finance lifestyles rather than to minister in, that the seeds of protestant non-conformity took root. The one good thing to come out of this period for Wales was the publication of the Bible in Welsh which stated the fact, to Welsh ears, that God was against the injustices that they so keenly felt. This would become even more important later, but to begin with these common people began to practice literacy and discuss concepts like "the priesthood of all believers" as the basis of their religious life. I deem this idea to be the origin of what was to emerge later as the rudiments of democratic thought and organisation amongst the protestant non-conformists, a model of democracy worked out by experiment.In the meantime, those who could afford it and who refused to go to Oxford and submit to protestant teachings went to the continental universities and were caught up in the Counter-Reformation. They returned to Wales, sometimes as priests, having been exposed to a catholic and classical education depicting ancient Rome and Athens, and also to radical writers like Machiavelli who discussed politics in a recognisably early-modern way, and sometimes they had actually visited functioning republics like Venice. Their Neo-Platonical conception of republicanism was very different from what we assume to be republican now a days : their idea was of a Christian philosopher-king who would frame the laws of the land and govern society according to God's will, and they most probably despised democracy : the people needed to be ruled not be rulers. In their cultivated world of recusancy they shared much with their English catholic co-religionists, save one thing : English catholics contended against English protestants to seize the English throne for their own candidate monarch, or atleast to influence the existing monarch, and as such they were enemies; but Welsh catholics and Welsh protestants shared a sense of being oppressed by whoever was on the English throne, and as such they had something in common to talk about.The conclusion drawn from that long dialectical conversation held between these two Welsh dissenting religious groups over two hundred years emerged in the 18c was a set of values and attitudes that we now take to be political and describe as "democratic and republican". In the early 16c however politics as we now concieve it just didn't exist, and the protestant cultures that emphasised the spiritual authority of the congregation seemed irreconcilable to the catholic cultures that asserted the authority of the priestly heirarchy. What transformed this conflict in Wales was the outcome of the consequences of the Annexation, Reformation and Dissolution : a severe social breakdown of Welsh society that resulted in everybody concerned craving law and order and being very angry with the laws and legal system that had been imposed on Wales by the Annexation.Again, if you read an English'd history of Wales you generally will be totally unaware of the steadily increasing incidences of starvation, rioting and crime that Wales become notable for in the 16c. At best, history books generally recount romantic anecdotal tales of bandits like Twm Sion Catti or pirates like John Callice and don't set them into context. The economic causes of crime were not just that the common people were moved onto marginal land but that Wales was now taxed in the same way as England and so the merchant trade collapsed for not having the same fat margins as England and so Wales as a maritime nation trading with Europe nearly ceased to exist, with all sorts of knock on consequences economically. Social causes included the factionalising and rivalry for political influence with the crown because that could procure land, the major source of wealth, and also it procured appointments to offices that could be exploited for money. Within the legal system, appointments such as sheriff were made by both political influence and straightforward bidding : having procured the office the incumbent set about retrieving his money by as many prosecutions and fines as possible and the laws that had Welshmen dragged into an English county and tried by juries consisting only of Englishmen persisted until 1628, when Henry IV's punitive laws against the Welsh were mostly, finally, repealed by Charles I. By 1628 however Wales was already entering a sort of national breakdown involving its sense of identity after a failed catholic rebellion in Monmouthshire in 1609. The Welsh tried to stay out of the later English civil wars and it is an irony that the last battle of these was fought in Wales when Laugharne decided to change sides to the king's cause, causing thousands of Welsh peasants to die needlessly on the fields of St Fagans.

David continues:
The English civil wars accelerated the first steps away from a Welsh identity built upon of catholic conformity and social heirarchy towards a one that embraced protestant non-conformity and egalitarianism, but the new protestant democratic spirit had come to inhabit a body of republican thought it inherited from catholicism - the two had become welded together through the longing for just laws and restored order in society that had increasingly haunted 16c Welsh society after its subjection to Annexation, Reformation, Dissolution and their further consequences. Much of the debate that created this fusion of democracy and republicanism must have taken place in the dissenting academies that sprang up to compensate for Wales not having a university, so it is not surprising that the 18c philosophers of democratic republicanism that sprang from Wales were the products of such institutions - nor should we imagine that they simply created it as an act of genius, clearly Williams and Price were drawing on the same political tradition and just articulating it for others. I am sure that this tradition began in the 16th century in Wales.
David Continues:
As I may have told you, I am working on the theory that nationalism and socialism in Wales parted way from republicanism somewhere between 1850 ( = date of "Red Republican" and introduction of Marxism ) and 1885 ( = first election in which the working class got the vote and started to concentrate on their own interests ). In between these dates I have presumed that the Welsh ( and Irish etc ) who had fought in the American Civil War had brought back a renewed version of republicanism to rejuvenate the old one that persisted after the collapse of Chartism. All over Britain and Ireland there was a revival in republicanism in the 1870's, and a number of clubs were founded to promote the cause - often called "radical" clubs to conceal their purpose, the last remaining Radical Club in South Wales as far as I know is in Blaenllechau, Rhondda but probably other clubs - even non-political ones - may have started out as radical clubs. The nationalists in Cymru Fydd clearly loathed them - their political idea was proclaimed as " Athenian Democracy reconciled to Roman Imperialism " - ie they wanted Home Rule but also wanted a share in Britain's loot.

My Comment: I would suggest that those of good 'Welsh Republican Mind' engage with David Lawrence in search for this lost ''Welsh Republican History'', also engage in discussion and debate. David as began to make of me a 'Welsh Republican Optimist', but must still critically and cynically condemn those who continue to be of ''Retro & Romantic'' in their ''Welsh Republicanism''. Those of both 'Cymru Rydd' and 'Balchder Cymru' whose Republican Foundations some what in a very bizzare way are based on the Ultra - Nationalist Militantism of FWA Commandants; Cayo and Coslett, their 'Welsh Republicanism'' and mine/Patriotic Front and other 1960's 'Adfywiadwyr Gwladgarol' had more to do with our total captivation of the the Irish Easter Rising (see 1966 in AWNM&S History Archive, regards 'Adfywiad Gwladgarol Fawr 1962/3 - 1969). Some what made more politically bizzare by fact that we were led then in the 60's by the ''Romantic Republicanism'' of the Patriotic Bard Harri Webb, where we found our ''Field of Dreams'' in a rather patriotic medievalism in the ''Saced Acre'' around the Cilmeri Cenotaph to the last prince of the Royal Family of Gwynedd, a Cymric Aristocracy that also claimed to be the over lords (High Kings) of Wales in theory but only 'Pura Walliae' in practise. Still to this day, the aforementioned ''R&R Republicans" are more often seen commemorating Medieval History and Princes than anything that has much to do with a ''Welsh Republicanism'' in any shape or form. Yes! Bizzare! I am guilty of such as much as others, but then I have never really been a 'Welsh Republican' but rather more a 'Welsh Remembrancer' so I have an excuse, how about you? Whatever, the truth is if we are to see a ''New Welsh Republicanism'' to emerge and be more succesful than before, then 'Welsh Republicans' will have need of their own ''sacred acre'' to assemble at, to hold annual Welsh Republican Rally. I have suggested Garreg Wasted but having read what David Lawrence has to say, I am now more in favour of his proposals for such an annual Rally of Republicans'.Read On:
Picture immediatly above is off a lone Welsh Republican Flag raised up at the aforementioned Cardiff Protest, the two pictures below were taken by David Lawrence (c) of the David Williams memorial in Caerffili.

David Writes:
This is the place that I am suggesting might be a pleasant spot for a summer rally - if it rains the Courthouse pub is fifty yards away, and it does nice meals although I had in mind a picnic. Caerphilly could hardly object to people comemorating its most distinguished son at the monument to him in the park named after him - even if we did dress the obelisk up with some republican flags and pledged allegiance to them as a symbol of the republic ! I'll try and write a bit about David Williams later. There's a worthy biography of him called "The Anvil and the Hammer" by Whitney R D Jones 1987. Williams influenced both the American and French revolutionists with newspaper articles, pamphlets and friendships that were widely quoted at the time but he left no literary monuments to his political and religious philosophies. Religiously, he fully broke completely off from the Christian faith and attempted to found a Deist religion that was to be one of the inspirations for the French revolutionary republic's attempt to found a state religion, "The Cult of Reason" - hence his nickname, "The Priest of Nature", because he retired to the countryside to perform novel rites. He made a living mostly by running a novel school in London, based on radical principles that incalcated a democratic and rational education, and partly by writing criticism for newspapers. His friends eventually contrived to procure for him a sort of pension in his old age in a job with the Royal Literary Fund - irony ! David Williams is particularly important to republican political theory in his arguing the right of people to take up arms to defend themselves against tyranical governments. He introduced the idea of the local "well regulated militias" that would be able to oppose the central government's standing army should it ever be used to oppress people. This was a key argument cited by the American revolutionaries. Thus he would be horrified by the fact that his idea, which was incorporated into the USA's constitution as the people's right to bear arms, is used to justify private people carrying fire-arms for personal self defence. David Williams would have viewed this as an invitation to anarchy, with the predictable result that murderous weapons would be in the hands of lawless individuals spreading havoc - instead martial armaments being in the hands of morally educated people who would be acting together under a military discipline to democratically defend the rule of law and order. The monument is in Parc Dafydd Williams, and inscription:
David Williams born at Waenwaelod Watford 1738 Died at London June 29 1816 Buried at St Annes Soho This memorial has been raised by a few admirers. He was one of the foremost Welshmen of his age and generation, endowed with rare intellectual gifts. He devoted the greater part of his life to the helping of the poor, the expounding of the principles of popular education, and the furthering of the cause of LIBERTY both in speech and in thought. He wrote many books. He drafted the first constitution of the FRENCH REVOLUTION. He shielded Benjamin Fanklin and other friends of freedom from persecution and he founded the Royal Literary Fund.

If you want to read more of David Lawrence's material on Welsh Republicanism, visit the forum below:
welshrepublican :: View Forum - ArchiveModerators: None Users browsing this forum: None ... No new posts, Vote for Ithel Davies - Vote Welsh Republican ! ( 1950 ) ...wales.6.forumer.com/viewforum.php?f=6&sid=32baaf8539cf06743dd3e7a2011cf118 - 50k - Cached - Similar pages
G.Gruffydd, Editor The Welsh Patriot blog.